Nintendo’s reputation for delivering polished, genre-defining games has been built over decades. Yet, even the most trusted gaming brands aren’t immune to missteps. In a surprising twist, two of the worst-reviewed games on the Nintendo Switch 2 come directly from Nintendo’s own first-party lineup—sparking debate among fans and critics about quality control and shifting priorities.
A Strong Console Launch with a Weak Link
The Nintendo Switch 2 has been widely praised for its hardware upgrades, improved performance, and backward compatibility, creating high expectations for its first wave of games. Many anticipated that Nintendo’s own releases would lead the charge in showcasing the console’s potential. However, two major titles have fallen short, receiving low scores from both critics and players.
Where These Games Missed the Mark
While Nintendo’s first-party titles are typically celebrated for their polish and creativity, these particular Switch 2 releases have been criticized for:
-
Repetitive gameplay loops that fail to evolve over time.
-
Lackluster visuals that don’t fully utilize the new hardware’s capabilities.
-
Performance hiccups such as frame rate drops and load time delays.
-
Underwhelming narratives compared to the studio’s usually strong storytelling.
The disappointment has been amplified by the fact that these games carry the Nintendo seal, which for many players, has traditionally signaled top-tier quality.
The Bigger Picture for Nintendo and Gamers
For Nintendo, this stumble serves as a reminder that brand legacy alone cannot sustain player trust—especially in an era where competition is fierce, and player expectations are higher than ever. It may also prompt a renewed focus on quality assurance and creative innovation for future Switch 2 titles.
For players, the lesson is clear: even first-party titles should be evaluated based on reviews and gameplay impressions before purchase. The Switch 2 remains a strong and appealing console, but not every game will be a must-buy.
Two disappointing first-party launches on the Switch 2 won’t erase decades of Nintendo excellence, but they do stand out as rare blemishes in the company’s history. Fans are now watching closely to see how Nintendo responds—and whether its next releases can restore the level of quality and excitement players have come to expect.